← All posts

2026-11-17 · 7 min read · Dallas-Fort Worth

How do you compare two offers on your house in Texas? It's not just the price

Title card for the article: How do you compare two offers on your house in Texas? It's not just the price

How do you compare two offers on your house in Texas when one has the higher price and the other looks safer? It's one of the biggest decisions in the whole sale.

You compare them by what lands in your hand and by how likely each is to reach closing, not by price alone. Financing, option days, earnest money, what happens if the appraisal comes in low, the closing date and what the buyer asks you to pay all change what an offer is really worth.

I'm Veronica Yeary, a Realtor® in Dallas-Fort Worth with All City Real Estate DFW. I help families sell their home and buy the next one, and self-employed buyers, step by step.

Here's what to look at in each offer, how to lay them side by side, and what changes when you're also buying.

For sellers

What's your home worth today?

I'll bring you your home's value in person, based on sales in your area. Free, no commitment.

Ask me what your home is worth

The short answer

  • Price is just the first line. What matters is your net after every cost and concession.
  • The second question is which one actually closes. A higher offer with more ways to fall apart can be worth less than a lower, firmer one.
  • Look at five things beyond price: how the buyer pays, how many option days they want, how much earnest money they put up, what happens if the appraisal is low, and the closing date.
  • If you're buying next, timing and a short stay after closing carry real weight. The best offer is the one that lets you move once.
  • You can work with one and accept the other as a backup. TREC has an addendum for a back-up contract.

What do you compare in each offer?

  1. Your net. Price, minus your payoff, minus your selling costs, minus whatever the buyer asks you to cover in their costs or repairs. Two offers at the same price can leave you with different amounts.
  2. How the buyer pays. Cash, conventional, FHA, VA or another program. Each has its own steps, timing and appraisal and inspection rules. The buyer's lender letter tells you how far along they are; read it, don't just check that it's attached.
  3. The option period. The window when the buyer can walk away for any reason with written notice, after paying the option fee. Fewer days means less time with your sale up in the air.
  4. Earnest money. The good-faith deposit, delivered to the escrow agent (usually the title company) by the contract deadline. Per TREC, if it doesn't arrive on time, the seller may terminate.
  5. The appraisal. If the buyer is financing, the lender sends an appraiser. If the value comes in under the price, the contract decides what happens next. TREC has an addendum on the buyer's right to terminate due to the lender's appraisal; if the offer includes it, read exactly what it lets the buyer do.
  6. Closing date and possession. When it closes and when you hand over the keys. If you need a few extra days, TREC has a Seller's Temporary Residential Lease.
  7. Special conditions. If the buyer needs to sell their own home first, the offer comes with the addendum for sale of other property. That adds a condition you don't control.

How do you lay two offers side by side?

The clearest way is one page with two columns. On the sales Veronica Yeary handles across Dallas-Fort Worth, that page gets built before any offer is answered. It includes:

  • Offered price.
  • What the buyer asks you to pay toward their costs, plus any repairs already requested.
  • Your net from each one, line by line.
  • How they're paying and how far along the loan is, per the lender letter.
  • Option days and option fee.
  • Earnest money.
  • What happens if the appraisal comes in low.
  • Closing date, and whether you can stay a few days.
  • Special conditions, like selling their home first.

With that page in front of you, the choice stops being "highest or safest" and becomes math. If you haven't listed yet and want to know your starting number now, get your home's real value, no commitment: veronicayeary.com/home-value.

What changes if you're also buying?

When you sell to buy, every offer touches your next home. An offer whose closing date doesn't match your purchase, or that won't let you stay a few days, can force you to move twice even if it brings more money.

Firmness matters too. If your purchase depends on this sale's proceeds, an offer with lots of conditions leaves you with two contracts in the air. Sometimes a slightly lower offer that closes on the date you need is the better deal.

So when you're selling and buying, the page gets one more row: how each offer fits your purchase. More on that in two negotiating tables when you sell and buy.

How do you answer once you have chosen?

Choosing isn't the same as signing. Once the math points to one offer, you still have three ways to respond, and each one sends a different message.

Accept it as written. If the terms already work, signing quickly keeps the buyer committed and starts the clock on the option fee and earnest money.

Counter it. If one or two terms don't fit, like the closing date or what you'd pay toward their costs, you counter just those. Keep the counter short and clear; a counter that changes everything reads like a new negotiation.

Hold the other as a backup. If the second offer is still good, ask whether that buyer would sign as a back-up contract. It costs you nothing to ask, and it gives you a plan B if the first one falls apart during the option period.

Whatever you choose, answer every buyer honestly and in a reasonable time. A buyer who was treated well is more likely to come back if the first deal doesn't close.

The mistakes that cost the most

  1. Choosing on price alone. That worked when offers looked alike. Today they vary a lot on concessions, option days and appraisal terms. Do the math first.
  2. Assuming cash always wins. A cash offer often closes with fewer steps, but it may come with a lower price or a date that doesn't work for you. More in a cash offer and where you will live next.
  3. Skimming the buyer's lender letter. A letter that only says "prequalified" isn't the same as one where documents were reviewed. Ask, with the buyer's permission, what has been checked.
  4. Ignoring the appraisal addendum. If it's there, it changes how likely the buyer is to stay if the value comes in low. Read it before you sign, not after.
  5. Answering in a rush. A decision this size deserves a few hours to run the numbers. Here's what happens next: the page, the math, then the answer.

An example

Picture a family in Plano who gets two offers the same weekend. The first has the higher price, a low-down-payment loan, asks the seller to cover part of the buyer's costs, and wants to close on a date that doesn't fit the family's own purchase. The second comes in a little lower, in cash, with few option days, a closing date that works, and room for the family to stay a few days after closing.

Side by side on one page, the difference in what they'd walk away with is smaller than it looked, and the second offer lets them move once. They choose the second and accept the first as a back-up contract in case anything changes. This is an illustration, not a real client.

What to check before you answer

  • The two-column page with your net from each offer.
  • Each buyer's lender letter, read in full.
  • Whether either includes the appraisal addendum or the sale-of-other-property addendum.
  • That the closing date fits your purchase, if you're buying.
  • If you need extra days, the seller's temporary lease.
  • That earnest money and the option fee reach the title company on time once signed.

TREC's forms are at trec.texas.gov. Your title company confirms your case.

Frequently asked questions

Should I always take the highest offer on my house?

Not always. Take the one that leaves you the most in hand and is most likely to close. That's why you compare concessions, financing, option days, appraisal terms and timing, not just price.

Is a cash offer better?

It usually has fewer steps and less appraisal risk, but it isn't automatically best. Compare it against your net and the date you need.

What is a back-up contract?

It's a second accepted offer that moves up if the first one falls through. TREC has an addendum for back-up contracts, signed separately from the main contract.

What if the buyer doesn't deliver earnest money on time?

Per TREC, if the buyer misses the earnest money deadline, the seller may terminate the contract. The title company confirms when it arrived.

Can I counter both offers at once?

It can be done carefully, but you need to know what happens if both accept. The usual approach is to answer one and keep the other as a backup or on hold.

Here's what happens next

Choosing between two offers is easier with the math done. And the math starts with your home's real value.

Get your home's real value, no commitment: veronicayeary.com/home-value

Call or text 469-441-8890 · veronica@veronicayeary.com

Veronica Yeary, Realtor® CRS · ABR · SRS · CIPS, All City Real Estate DFW.

For sellers

What's your home worth today?

I'll bring you your home's value in person, based on sales in your area. Free, no commitment.

Ask me what your home is worth

The method

Where this fits in how I sell a home